Back
EssayNov ’222 min read

A badge is a promise about what was checked

Twitter’s paid blue check turned into a wave of impersonation within two days. A badge is a promise that someone checked something, and once it can be bought, nobody can tell what was checked.

Typeface

Twitter launched paid verification on November 9. For $8 a month, anyone could get the blue check that used to mean Twitter had confirmed who an account belonged to. A gray “official” label for notable accounts was announced alongside it, then dropped by Elon Musk within hours.

Engadget has the timeline of what followed. A verified account posing as Nintendo. A verified account posing as Eli Lilly, announcing that insulin was now free. By November 11, Twitter had paused new Blue signups and said it would bring back the “official” label “to combat impersonation.” Musk’s summary was “Tricking people is not okay.”

The blue check was a short answer to a question people had every time they read a tweet from a brand, a reporter or a public figure: is this really them?

A badge is a promise that someone checked something, and the moment it can be bought without the check, it promises nothing. The new check still looks identical to the old one. For a few days, the same mark meant “Twitter confirmed this identity” on some accounts and “this account pays $8” on others, and nobody reading could tell which.

That’s worse than having no badge at all. Without a badge, people stay careful. With a badge they can’t interpret, they trust the wrong accounts.

I learned to be strict about status marks designing tools for engineers. On Uber’s experimentation platform, a flag is marked degraded when one of its guardrail metrics passes its limit, and that’s all the mark means. An engineer seeing it at 3 a.m. knows exactly what was checked and what failed.

A status mark has to work like that wherever people rely on it:

  • It means one thing, and that thing is written down somewhere people can find.
  • The mark looks different when the thing being certified is different.
  • It can be taken away when the thing it certifies stops being true.

Selling a subscription is fine. Selling it with the same mark that meant identity was the mistake. If Twitter wants both, it needs two marks that look nothing alike, and it needs to say plainly what each one means.