Back
NoteOct ’222 min read

Provenance has to show up where trust is decided

Adobe says it will label who made content and whether AI was involved. Shutterstock will pay artists whose work trained DALL·E. Both need a record of where an image came from, and that record only matters if people see it at the right moment.

Typeface

Two announcements this month point at the same missing piece.

At Adobe MAX on October 18, Scott Belsky wrote that Adobe’s generative AI would be “creator-centric” and that it “never seeks to replace human imagination and judgment.” Adobe plans to use the Content Authenticity Initiative’s standards to show who made a piece of content and whether generative AI was involved.

On October 25, Shutterstock announced that DALL·E 2 will be built into its site in the coming months, along with a Contributor Fund to pay artists whose images were used to train OpenAI’s models. How much, and how it’s calculated, hasn’t been said. Shutterstock also won’t accept AI-generated images made outside its own tool.

Both plans depend on a record of where an image came from. Adobe’s labels need one to say whether AI was involved. Shutterstock’s fund needs one to know whose work went in.

The record is the engineering problem. The design problem is the reader. A record of where something came from only works if it shows up at the moment someone decides whether to trust it. Metadata in a file that nobody opens protects no one. A small mark that says “made with AI” on the image itself, in the feed, at the size people actually see it, changes how they read it.

I’ve designed a version of this for engineers. In Uber Studio, you could pick any request a simulated rider made and open its trace beside it: every service it touched and how long each one took. It answered “where did this come from?” in place, next to the thing in question, without a trip to another system.

Content provenance needs the same shape. The answer should sit beside the image, a tap away, at the moment of doubt. A label buried in an export setting or a settings page won’t do that.

Neither company has shown that interface yet, and the details will decide whether it works. What does the mark look like at the size of a thumbnail? What does it say when an image was edited by a person and then by a model? And will the platforms where images actually spread keep the record attached at all? Adobe can design the label. It only works if everyone else displays it.