Back
NoteJan ’242 min read

A key is a permanent promise

Microsoft is putting a Copilot key on Windows keyboards, its first keyboard change in nearly three decades. A physical key is the most permanent entry point a platform can hand out.

Typeface

On January 4, Microsoft announced a Copilot key for Windows PCs, calling it “the first significant change to the Windows PC keyboard in nearly three decades.” According to TechCrunch, it takes the place of the right Control key. Where Copilot isn’t available, the key opens Windows Search instead.

The news coverage was mostly about AI. What interests me is how much permanence Microsoft just gave away.

Every platform has a short list of places that are always there: the home button, the lock screen, the notification shade, the keys. Anything that lands in one of those places is seen by everyone who uses the device, whether they asked for it or not. Most of my work on Android is about one of those places, what a shared screen shows before anyone unlocks it, and I’ve come to think the scarcest thing a platform owns is a permanent spot.

A key is the most permanent spot of all. A menu can be reordered in an update. A key ships in plastic and stays on the desk for as long as the laptop does.

Two details in the announcement bother me.

The first is that the key changes meaning depending on where you are. In one country it opens an assistant, and in another it opens search. A key that does different things on different machines is hard to learn, and it’s harder still to write instructions for.

The second is what it replaced. The right Control key isn’t popular, but the people who rely on it rely on it all day, for one-handed shortcuts and remapped layouts. Those people pay for the new key so that everyone else can find Copilot.

A key can’t be redesigned after it ships, so it should only ever be given to something that will still deserve it in ten years. Escape, Delete and the Windows key have earned that over decades. An assistant from 2024 might earn it too. Nobody knows yet, including Microsoft.

If I were making the call, I’d ship the assistant behind a key that already exists, measure how often people reach for it, and print a new key only after the number says it belongs there. That’s slower, and it’s a weaker story at CES. It’s also the order every other decision about a permanent spot should follow: earn the place, then take it.