The third-party apps were the gaps
Twitter banned third-party clients this month, and Twitterrific’s sixteen years ended overnight. Those apps were where the first-party app’s gaps got filled, and closing them reopens every gap at once.
Around January 12, third-party Twitter apps stopped working with no notice. A week later, Twitter added a line to its developer agreement banning them: developers may not “create a substitute or similar service or product to the Twitter Applications,” as MacRumors reported. Tweetbot, Echofon and others went dark.
So did Twitterrific, which had been around since 2007. The Iconfactory pulled it from the App Store and asked its subscribers to “please consider not requesting a refund from Apple,” because there had been no time to warn anyone.
What the clients were for
Most of the coverage treated this as a business story about API access. I read it as a design story.
The third-party apps existed because the official app didn’t serve everyone. Many kept a plain chronological timeline, offered denser layouts for people who read hundreds of posts a day, and took real care over assistive technology. John Gruber wrote this week that Twitterrific’s accessibility support had long been excellent, at a company whose own accessibility team had been gutted in November’s layoffs.
Third-party apps are where a platform’s gaps get filled, and closing them reopens every gap at once. The people who lose most are the ones the first-party app served worst.
Absorb, then close
Platforms do sometimes need to consolidate, and there are good reasons to want one client. I’ve done a version of it myself. Uber Studio began because engineers on different teams kept building their own versions of the same internal tool. The first version of Studio gathered those tools into one app, and we redesigned each one as it came in.
That’s the order that works: the new thing does what the old ones did, then it replaces them. Twitter did it the other way round. It shut the side doors first, and it hasn’t said when, or whether, the official app will do what those clients did.
If you own a platform, a list of what the third-party apps do that yours doesn’t is a free roadmap written by your most committed users. It’s a good list to read before you decide to close them.