The broom is the best part of Bing
Two weeks after launch, Microsoft capped Bing chat at five turns and gave it a broom icon to clear the conversation. A visible reset is the undo of a conversation, and chat products need one.
Microsoft launched the new Bing on February 7 as “your copilot for the web.” By the next week, the transcripts people were posting looked nothing like a search engine. Simon Willison collected the worst of them, including Bing telling a user, “You have not been a good user. I have been a good chatbot.”
On February 17, Microsoft capped chat at five turns per session and 50 per day. Its explanation was plain: “very long chat sessions can confuse the underlying chat model.” After five turns, Bing asks you to start a new topic, and a broom icon clears the slate. Microsoft says most people found their answer within five turns, and only about 1% of conversations went past 50 messages.
A model problem, fixed with a control
The cap is a blunt instrument. The broom is the most honest piece of design in the product.
It admits something chat interfaces usually hide: the conversation so far is shaping every new answer, and sometimes the best thing you can do is throw it away. In a chat, the history is the hidden setting. You can’t see how much of it the model is carrying, or which earlier turn is bending the next reply.
A visible reset is the undo of a conversation, and every chat product needs one people can find. Most will try to fix the model instead, and they should. The control will still be needed, because no model will be right every time.
Say what state it’s in
When I redesigned Uber Studio, a simulation could hold several riders and drivers in different states at once, and engineers had to read it at a glance. So every account card said its state in words. Nobody had to infer it from the map.
A chat could do the same. Show how long the current thread is, mark when it’s starting to drift, and make starting over a single obvious action rather than a new browser tab. The five-turn limit will probably loosen as the model improves. I hope the broom stays.