A shared space needs a protective default
Meta turned on a Personal Boundary of almost four feet around every avatar in Horizon Worlds, by default. In a shared space, the default has to protect whoever has the least power to change it.
Last Friday, Meta added a Personal Boundary to Horizon Worlds and Horizon Venues. Other avatars can’t come closer than a set distance, which works out to almost four feet between people. It’s on by default. If you want a high-five or a fist bump, you have to reach out your arm.
Meta’s explanation for the default is the most interesting line in the post: a default like this “may set behavioral norms” in a new medium. That’s right, and it’s a more honest description of what defaults do than most companies give.
Who changes the setting
In a private app, a default is a convenience. Most people keep it, and the few who care change it.
In a shared space, the people who would change a default are rarely the people it protects. The person most likely to be harassed in a crowded virtual room is also the person least likely to stop, open a menu and find the right setting while it’s happening. In a shared space, the default has to protect the person with the least power in the room, because they’re the one least able to change it.
Meta got the order right. The protection is on for everyone, and nobody walking up to you can override it.
The norm comes from the system
Shared screens at home have the same problem in a quieter form. A smart display on a kitchen counter or a TV in a living room belongs to a family, a household, whoever is in the room. Whatever it shows by default, it shows to everyone, including the people who didn’t set it up.
The lesson I’d take from Horizon is that the norms of a shared space are designed, whether anyone means to design them or not. A space with no boundary has a norm too. It’s just one nobody chose. Ship the protective version first, watch how people use it, and loosen it only where the evidence says it’s safe. At Uber, new features went out behind a flag to a few people at a time, and a boundary can loosen the same way. Going the other way means learning about the harm from the people who were harmed.
It’s also worth naming the cost. A four-foot bubble makes some kinds of closeness harder, and some people will find the space colder for it. I think that’s a fair trade for a medium this new, and Meta can always let trusted friends inside it later. Starting permissive and adding protection later would be the harder fix.