Back
NoteAug ’232 min read

Consent belongs in the room

Zoom rewrote its terms this week after people found AI training among the uses of their meetings. In a meeting, the people affected by a setting are everyone on the call, so the consent has to happen there too.

Typeface

Last weekend people noticed that section 10.4 of Zoom’s terms of service, updated in March, listed “machine learning, artificial intelligence” among the things Zoom could do with customer content. By Monday Zoom had posted an explanation, and within about a day the wording was gone. The terms now say Zoom “will not use audio, video or chat Customer Content to train our artificial intelligence models without your consent.”

That’s better. It also leaves the interesting question open: whose consent?

A terms of service is a contract with one account. A meeting is a room with many people in it. Zoom’s AI features show a consent flow, and the account that turns them on is usually the host’s or an admin’s. The other people on the call, from other companies or no company at all, never signed anything with that host.

In a meeting, everyone on the call is affected by what happens to it, so consent has to be asked in the call, where they all are. A clause the host’s admin accepted a year ago doesn’t reach them.

I’ve spent a lot of time on shared surfaces. In 2020 I worked on meetings and calls for Slack, and now I work on a tablet a whole household uses. Both taught me the same thing. Anything that changes what happens to people in a shared space needs a signal everyone in that space can see, at the moment it matters.

Recording already works this way on most platforms: a visible indicator, and a notice when you join. AI features that use what’s said in a meeting should get the same treatment:

  • A notice on join that says what the AI will do with the call, in one sentence.
  • An indicator that stays on screen while it’s doing it.
  • A way for a participant to say no that doesn’t require leaving.

The last one is the hard one, and it may not always be possible. Meeting tools will need to decide, explicitly, what happens when one person declines and the rest don’t. That decision belongs in the product, where people can see it. Zoom’s week shows what happens when it’s left to the terms.