Back
NoteMay ’242 min read

The map won the space

In Uber Studio’s 2017 redesign we drew the message stream as a permanent column and as a drawer. The columns showed more. The drawer won, because a panel that is always open is paid for by everything beside it, all the time.

Typeface

When we redesigned Uber Studio in the fall of 2017, a simulation had three things that all wanted the screen. There were the accounts in it, the map they moved across, and the stream of messages and traces the system produced as they moved. Studio was where Uber’s engineers ran a trip from a desk, and all three mattered to that.

We drew two answers. One put the accounts in a column and the stream in a drawer under the map. The other gave the accounts and the stream a column each, beside the map.

In higher fidelity we pushed the columns, and they were good. They gave every account room for its whole state and every message room for its contents. They also took a third of the map, all the time.

The map won the space. The accounts sit in one column of cards over it, and the stream sits in a drawer under it that opens when you need it. Pick a request in the drawer and its trace opens beside it: every service it touched, and how long each one took. As a column, all of that would cost a third of the map all the time. As a drawer it costs nothing until you open it.

The columns were better at something real. With the stream always open, you could read every account’s whole state and every message’s contents without asking for them. The drawer gives that up. Reading a trace became a step you take.

I’d make the same call again, and the reason generalises. A permanent panel is paid for by everything beside it, every minute the screen is open, whether anyone is reading it or not. A drawer charges only when it’s used. So the question for any panel is how often someone needs it against what it takes from the thing they’re watching the rest of the time. On a screen where trips move across a city, that thing is the map.

Plenty of screens keep a panel open by default because nobody priced it. Studio’s stream was full of useful information, and it still went in the drawer.