A prompt is a brief
DALL·E 2 draws whatever you describe and offers several versions to choose from. Writing the description and choosing between results are skills creative directors already have.
OpenAI announced DALL·E 2 on April 6. Describe an image and it draws it. TechCrunch walked through what it can do. You can select part of an existing image, describe what should be there instead, and pick from several versions that match the light and shadows around them. You can ask for variations of an image, or blend two together. It’s invite-only for now, limited to “G-rated” output, and its training data had violent imagery removed. In TechCrunch’s words, the model “doesn’t even know what a missile strike is.”
The Next Web framed it as both a promise and a threat for graphic designers, architects and product designers.
The brief was always the hard part
Earlier in my career I was a creative director, and a lot of that job was writing briefs. A good brief says what the work is for, who it’s for, what must be true and what’s open. A weak one says “make it pop” and gets back whatever the designer would have done anyway.
A prompt is a creative brief for a collaborator who can’t ask questions, and the brief is where most of the work gets decided. DALL·E 2 will fill every gap in a description with something. If you didn’t say what the light should do, it decides. If you didn’t say who the image is for, it makes it for nobody in particular.
That makes the brief matter more. The people who’ll get the most from these tools are the ones who already know how to say what they want before they see it.
Picking is a skill too
The other half of DALL·E 2’s interface is choosing. You don’t get one answer. You get several, and you pick.
Designers do this all the time. When I redesigned Uber Studio, the first question was where three things should live on one screen, and we drew two answers before committing to one. Knowing which answer was right, and being able to say why, was the real work.
What I’d watch
I don’t think this replaces designers soon, and I’m wary of anyone who says it will. It does change where the effort goes. Less of it will be in making the first version, and more in saying precisely what’s needed, then choosing well among things that all look finished. Those are senior skills. I’d expect the tools to make them more valuable, and the people without them to have a harder time telling a good result from a plausible one.